Basket Case

So much for making my mention of the purple sock series a little quickie throwaway. OK, OK, screaming throng! More on this subject. Not an actual pattern yet, as such, but some further discussion and eventually some recipe-ish guidelines.

First of all, the requisite assurance: definitely no Third Sock Syndrome, and apparently no Fourth Sock Syndrome either. I finished #3 on Sunday and cast on almost immediately for #4.

Purple Basket Sock and a Half

It wasn’t all plain sailing getting there, though. Did anybody besides me notice the whacking big mistake in the picture of this from the previous post?

Here’s a hint:

Purple Basket Sock Mistake

The basket weave pattern is supposed to alternate directions. But there’s one place where…

Purple Basket Sock Mistake

… it doesn’t. Let’s hear it for blogging. I hadn’t actually noticed that until I looked at the picture.

Phooey. At first I thought I could get around it with the old demi-frog.

Purple Basket Sock Demi-Frog

No such luck. Because the crossed stitches are so loose until you cross them, they eat an unusual amount of yarn per row, and when you’re not working the basket-y pattern all the way around the sock the right-leaning row differs substantially from the left-leaning row because of the extra framing stitches. Not only was this more trouble than it was worth… it wouldn’t have worked anyway. So I sucked it up and full-frogged back to before the mistake.

Sigh.

So anyway… the stitch here is from Barbara Walker, Vol. I. She calls it Crochet-Knit Cross Stitch, and I’ve adapted it for working in the round, alternating the two variations to produce the basket-weave pattern. Basically it’s a four-row pattern - in the odd-numbered rows you create the elongated stitches by double-wrapping each one around the needle, and in the even-numbered rows you cross them like cables, two over two. First left, then right.

This is fine for the top of the foot, but it poses a problem for the ankle if you’re working it all the way round, because, being all-over-cabled, it has very little lateral give, and correspondingly an unusual degree of vertical stretch - in fact, it works very much like the old Chinese Finger Trap. So the sock is tight, not in the usual problem spot - i.e. the heel/instep angle - but in the ankle itself, which at a normal stitch count doesn’t stretch enough to allow the heel to pass through. I had built in one of my usual pseudo-gusset increase schemes before the short-row heel, and I quickly discovered that I was going nowhere fast if I also used the usual decrease scheme after the heel. So I didn’t decrease at all, and kept the extra eight stitches going up the ankle.

Purple Basket Sock on Foot

That’s an extra inch, and it’s just barely enough. I decided it was enough, for me, but though the sock fits nicely once it’s on it’s difficult to put on, which is why I’m still thinking of it in kids-do-not-try-this-at-home terms. Before I’d make a formal pattern out of it I’d want to work out a way to squeeze in some more increases above the heel. Can’t do them before the pattern section or the fabric will balloon out; can’t easily do them in pattern because the pattern doesn’t lend itself to gradual increases. I do have a notion in my noggin about a way to slip them into the transition point, but frankly for now I just want to HAVE these socks and I don’t have time to put a lot of complex engineering into them at the moment. Not, that is, unless the world out there would be happy to see me delay the standalone leaf pattern, and the shipping of Firebird, and the public release of Cleopatra, not to mention Swan Lake, and the next club sock after Firebird, and… well, you see where that line of thought leads. That way madness lies, and I’m crazy enough already.

That said, there’s no reason you couldn’t do a version of this sock with the basket-y stuff on the top and front only. Or take on the all-round version, with the clear understanding that in its present form it is just NOT going to work for the really deep of heel or the high of instep.

The first pair, however, the pair I made for Ada, was subject to no such strictures. That sock was built from a Turkish toe-tip cast-on, my usual 14 wraps (i.e. 28 stitches) increasing to a circumference of 64 stitches. Plain stockinette up the foot. A series of 4 sets of paired increases in the 1-1/2 inches before the heel. A wrap-&-turn short-row heel, Woolly Nylon held with the yarn for reinforcement. Three sets of the increased stitches decreased out above the heel, the last two left there because I needed a multiple of 6 for the ankle. The basket-y business on the ankle is a simple knit-purl texture thing: k3, p3 around for 4 rounds, then switch to p3, k3 around for 4 rounds. No reason you couldn’t do it on top of the foot as well… only… well, I didn’t. No particular reason, except maybe that this is a fairly dense fabric and I was concerned about bulk inside a shoe. (Of course, I then up and contradicted myself by doing the double-thick basket-weave thing on the present pair, but - well, it was an experiment and it was for me, and I decided I liked it. If you’re expecting rational and consistent all the time… you should probably be reading some other blog.)

If I’d had a little more time to think about it I would probably have done that toe a little differently - would have done what I did this time, which is a provisional cast-on and a short-row toe, with the reinforcing nylon added on the bottom only, that being where I’m hardest on my all-wool socks. Being half a size smaller than Ada, I used a slightly smaller circumference for my pair; even though I was getting my normal gauge of 8 SPI the thicker yarn means the fabric is not only denser but a little less resilient. I needed a multiple of 4, so I went to 60 stitches instead of 64. I started with a 30-st provisional cast-on, shamelessly borrowing a neat trick suggested by a friend on Ravelry: I substituted a toe-tip-style cast-on in place of the normal provisional set-up. I did a 30-wrap Turkish cast-on and started the short rows from one side of that, leaving the other needle in place. This way when the toe is finished there is nothing to unzip or pick up - no waste yarn, no extraneous motion - when you finish your toe you just arrive at the other needle and poof, you’re working in the round. Elegant. Thanks, Madmoon!

There are 4 sets of increases, so the ankle is 68 stitches, still the necessary multiple of 4, ending in 2×2 rib. Further deponent sayeth not, for now, except… that I’m vaguely thinking of this sock as “Footbasket,” because - well, if there’s enough yarn left (and I rather hope there will be) I’m thinking of making a pair of fingerless mitts with the same stitch on the back, and of course I would call those… “Handbasket.” What else?

Do I have basket-weave on the brain? Funny you should ask. Yes. Yes, I do. In a not-at-all-unrelated development, I’ve used an even smaller and less forgiving basket-weave stitch for the body of the Firebird. Tricky to work with because it has no stretch AT ALL so you can’t use much of it on a sock without doing all kinds of tricks to compensate - or waving goodbye to any semblance of ease. But worth it. Look.

Basket and Feathers

See how purty? And that’s just an early swatch, not even the real yarn or the real context.

This is:

Firebird Basket-weave

Hee. Just wait’ll you see the rest….

25 Responses to “Basket Case”

  1. Lynne Says:

    See the MISTAKE??? On my monitor, I’m lucky I can see the sock! I see lovely red-violet variegated pebbly looking things in the shape of a sock - which doesn’t help much. Of course, once you give the closeup, it’s pretty obvious… but it’s one of those things that only one of us obsessed perfectionists would really care a whole lot about - it would sure pass the horseback test!

    And I am muchly enamored of that hint of feathery shapes along the edge of the yummy finicky basketweave on Firebird….

  2. Caroline M Says:

    I had to look twice to see the mistake, even after you’d pointed it out. If they’d been for me I’d have left it (and you need to know that I NEVER leave a mistake unfixed). There again if they’d been for me I’d not have been working the pattern on the foot anyway because I always work plain below the heel.

    Firebird is looking good, there goes my “plain below the heel” rule then.

  3. Liz Says:

    I was going to say the same thing. Even when you pointed it out, I couldn’t see the mistake. Therefore, I probably would have said, “No one will notice!”

  4. lawre Says:

    Now, after seeing these wonderful socks, I am even MORE excited about the sock club.. LOVE all the beautiful patterns- GOODY,GOODY,GOODY!!!!!!!!!

  5. Maria Says:

    Wow, I am in awe, and I really wish you could come sit in my living room for when I need help understanding the technical aspects of knitting. Also to continuously design incredibly cool socks that I’d get to admire.

    Would you mind?

  6. chalyn Says:

    i love.

    thats it, just love. no, thats not entirely true… i covet also. now excuse me while i go off to contemplate the perfecting of my skillset so that i can attempt this basketweave thingy.

  7. Waltraud Says:

    Yes, and??? So I have to wait for the Firebird to actually arrive at my doorstep? Man, Lisa, you sure know how to create suspense! Grrrr.

  8. Nephele Says:

    I’m with Waltraud - you’re such a tease. I want my Firebird kit now!

  9. Emilie (also Arianne) Says:

    I LOVE the basket stitch socks! And I can’t wait for the first of the club. It’s been a whole year since I’ve wanted my own club. :)

  10. Byde Says:

    Oh man, that’s some pretty yarn. You’re making me hate my project on the needles, because all my love is for Firebird now. Wantwantwant…

  11. Nori Says:

    *Squeeee!*

    So excited about Sock Club. Finally, I can drool over the pretties on your blog without feeling the pangs of deprivation :)

  12. Ronni Says:

    Wow, thanks for sharing all that on your blog. I learn so much reading blogs like yours. I’m pretty sure I need to knit a lot more for a lot longer before I will get to where I can really comprehend and use much of what I learn but it’s the carrot that keeps me working at learning the thing I need to learn now. Right now, I need to learn how to read my own knitting better. I think, but am not sure, that I made a mistake in a sock. But since I wasn’t certain and it was finished and its mate was almost finished and despite puzzling over it for over an hour I couldn’t figure out what it was and I was wanting to be done, I decided to pretend I didn’t and just forge ahead with finishing the second sock and move on. I’m not sure if that’s personal growth (I tend to be a perfectionist and should drop some of that trait sometimes at least) or laziness.

  13. teeweewonders Says:

    Even if the pattern doesn’t work all that well on a sock from a “putting on” point of view, it looks nothing short of amazing!

  14. Maria Says:

    Ok, this is just too much. I’m not even a sock person, not to mention we are trying to buy a house, but the sock club is looking SOOOO enticing.

    I know, we can’t live in a sock, but wow, it’s tempting.

  15. Tishkette Says:

    Just coming out of the closet to say that I read screaming throng as screaming thong, and thought that people were throwing metaphorical undies at you in appreciation of your tsocks. I know I do (in my mind, that is).

  16. Sharon Rose Says:

    Woo hoo for the screaming thong! :)

    Thanks for sharing, Lisa! *hug*

  17. Knitterotica Says:

    I want a spoon so I can eat that beautiful color way in the last picture. I’ve seen sorbet that didn’t look that edible.

    The basket weave is purty too.

  18. geeky Heather Says:

    Baskety socks Soooo pretty! Firebird…stunning!!! Stupid stash diet.

    I did almost pass out when I saw the demi-tink, though. *gasp!*

  19. Gina Says:

    Love the look of the basket weave, too bad they are hard to put on…hope you solve that one!
    Really enjoy reading about the process and why it works or doesn’t thank you for sharing! And by the way, is there one really upset person in your household with yesterdays retirement announcement… no more #4…

  20. Karen Says:

    You walk a fine line, oh Tsarina — remember Tantalus’ fate. Oh, but you will be prepared after having knit the fine Handbaskets, not so?

    Elegant stuff, most alluring.

    Cheers and regards

  21. Susan Says:

    I was mentally speculating on that pattern and boy, was I ever off. I need to get me a Barbara Walker book; it seems as if the mysteries of the knitting world are solved there.

  22. Helen Darmara Says:

    Couldn’t you add four stitches in two spots (centered double increase on either side of a seam band in the uneven row. That way, you’d be able to do the 2×2 cables on the next row with the right number of stitches.

    You could repeat every fourth row. I don’t know how many extra stitches you’d need.

    It’s a really gorgeous stitch pattern.

    I’m halfway through Vintage — one sock down, four more leaves to knit…

  23. Suzanne Says:

    Except for the double wrapping we’d worked it out mostly. That and the offset. D’oh! Fun pattern, though. :) Thanks for sharing! I second needing a stitch treasury. :D

  24. Jennifer Says:

    Appreciate the way you wrote it all up. Fun to follow the process. You have high powers of sticking-to-it.

  25. Today I Am a Knitter « Moominmama’s Memoirs Says:

    […] this is not Extreme Frogging, as practised by Some People.  No, this is small, and modest.  But for someone who was […]

Leave a Reply